Bilal Powell: Stay or Go?
We all like to be able to make definitive statements evaluating the NFL. Uncertainty leaves us with little to talk about. Sometimes we really just need to wait and see. I have seen some deem Bilal Powell a bust already. That seems extremely premature. He only had one year in the league. Entering the season as the fourth running back on the depth chart, he was never going to see much time. This year was all about learning and practice for the future. He only had 14 touches as a rookie. That is way too limited of a sample size to make any judgment.
Granted, Powell's touches were not terribly impressive. He averaged 1.6 yards per rush on 13 carries. He also had a goal line fumble. I still have the same questions about him I had on Draft day. He does not look very fast. Once he gets going at full speed, he looks like a difficult guy to bring down, but it takes him a long time to accelerate. Backs who cannot get up to top speed in a hurry in the NFL usually get brought down before they have a chance to do so.
A handful of preseason and a few regular season carries are hardly enough to get a complete evaluation on a player, though. He will probably get more of a chance this coming year as the third guy on the depth chart. Maybe he will grow as a player.
I vote stay.
17 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Depends.
If Trent Richardson falls to us in the first round, or David Wilson falls to us in the second round, then you keep McKnight as a 3rd string back and give Powell the boot. If we stick with Greene as the feature back, then you keep him and develop him for one more year.
"Show me a good loser and I'll show you an idiot."
Leo Durocher
I'm on Twitter: @LiveLoveNYJets
Frequent blogger for GGN and MTD
Staff Blogger for nflmocks.com
by LiveLoveNYJets on Jan 22, 2012 12:21 PM EST reply actions
This.
And the home of the .... JETS!!!
Now lets get a G-D snack!!!
"You might not like that. You might be very cynical about that. Well, f**k it, I don't care what you think."-Roy McDonald
by Noble_Lance on Jan 22, 2012 12:24 PM EST up reply actions
He is pretty dang agile
i guess we know why now
Bilal powell has been totally un impressive
and has a very slow first couple of steps. If he dosen’t have a totally great camp i don’t think he will be a Jet. I would be very excited to see Trent Richardson available at 16, but one thing that scares me from watching his highlight tape. It seems like he takes these long first steps and needs a bit longer to hit his stride. I don’t know if it will be a problem in the NFL. any thoughts or am i being too critical?
I voted stay
He hasn’t been given a shot to prove himself at all but with LT gone he can get some time on the field. BUT I am upset that the FO drafted him in the first place, there were still some OLB prospects on the board at the time, it was a stupid pick. He is pretty much a clone of Greene, big, hard to bring down, and SLOW. I hate how this team refuses to get a real threat at RB. If you want to be a run first team get a runningback who can threaten to take it to the house on any given play, not a guy who can get chased down after 30 yards.
Powell has moderate speed in a sub-210 pound body
I vote stay because you can’t pull the plug on him already especially since he has a muted role, but the pick was a bad one. A 1 year wonder that doesn’t have great size or speed, to be the #4 back, with a 4th round pick? Terrible.
by J-Nasty on Jan 22, 2012 3:51 PM EST via mobile reply actions
Go
Dude has shown absolutely nothing. He hasn’t made anybody miss, hasn’t run through any tackles, hasn’t run away from anybody. He stinks.
He’s small and he runs small. He’s small and he’s slow and he lacks the quick twitch lateral agility to shake himself loose in tight spaces.
Cut him and draft/sign a real back.
by Crackback on Jan 22, 2012 4:31 PM EST via mobile reply actions
Hated the pick
when it was made and I see this guy as a complete bust. Another example of the Jets picking a slow running back with no breakaway talent. I would just release him and find a replacement in the 6th or 7th round.
40% say go.
14 touches and thats enough for half of us to sell him up the river. Haha
Good thing fans don’t run footbll teams or we all would have cut Joe Mcknight the second he puked in camp.
Joe at least flashed something in camp, and during his rookie season. Don’t take much for a back to show his talent. You don’t see many getting by on being technically sound. You either have it or your don’t. And if you have it, then you’re most like going to see SOMETHING at some time or another.
Crack, Joe flashed more of his stomach contents then he did anything else in camp his rookie year.
So much so that the word coming out of camp was that he was vastly out of shape and even labled a complete bust from the same number of fans as Powell is now (possibly even more).
And this Kid had even less time in camp than any other from the years prior.
Your jumping the gun.
The word from scouts was that this kid ran the ball from an almost exclusive “zone blocking scheme” in college. Something the Jets were not doing much of when Blial was getting his shots.
He’s a “one cut and go” type with quick feet and he’s the teams best shot at replacing LT’s ability to protect Mark from the RB position. He was picking up the blitz better in college then Joe or Greene were doing after multiple years in the league.
Any reps this kid ever had were rife with simple rookie mistakes. The jumpy nature in the backfield, the timid reluctance to be a little creative outside of play design. Even his one fumble on the goal line. It’s all rookie stuff.
If you look at his stats and especially his play style and running nature he screams of a possible Thomas Jones type runner who needs a little patience and the kind of touches he is bound to flourish with under Sparanos run heavy system.
I even like the way he carries the ball. High and tight like Tiki Barber did after he fixed his fumbling problems. That means he was well coached to boot.
In fact, pound for pound and inch for inch this kid seems like he was cut from TJ’s mold almost completely.
His game in Mobile had Scouts very high on him. He finishes every single run with hard running and displayed a great ability to keep his legs churning for extra yards.
There is absolutely no reason to give up on the kid after a nonexistant camp and limited touches during the season with an offense that could be described at the least as “ineffective” and even “lost” at times.
Give the kid a break. He may show us something next year.
Joe was flashing on punt returns and making a bunch of nifty runs during his rookie pre-season. What you talking? He had a bit of the fumbles (which is common in rookies) but it was clear the kid had talent. He flashed it all over the place. He looked like a guy that was extremely talented that just needed to put it together.
Powell looks like a little boy amongst men. I haven’t seen him flash a single thing. Not once. What he was in college was a straight line runner that was fast enough and strong enough to get it done on THAT level. He’s not fast enough or strong enough at the THIS level to get it done. Maybe I’m wrong, and I hope I am, but this kid has gotten enough looks to show at least something.
Your down playing Joe's problems.
Rex got so fed up with Joe’s fumbling and lack of prepairedness that he took to the media and practically threatened his spot on the team as a result in front of reporters.
And I’m confused by your statement that Powell was a strait line runner. Louisville ran zone for the kid almost all the time. Thats anything but strait line. Fair enough though. I won’t fight you on it. If you think 15 touches is enough thats cool. I think the kid deserves a full camp and a real chance in preseason under new regime.
We’ll see what happens.
he's a rookie
who didn’t get training camp. give him another year or 2
"You can't believe everything you read on the Internet"
-Abraham Lincoln

by 



















