In the spirit of draft season i thought it be fun rating the last 5 drafts(excluding last yr) from both NY/NJ teams. Excluding the bad picks and ranking the rest by grade A's through C's. A+. ranking among the best in the game. A. Pro Bowl/future Pro Bowler. A-. Knocking on the Pro Bowl door. and so on.
Both teams do it a little different Jets tend to really go after guys they like while the Giants tend to wait and find gems later. Also not rating trades because its hard to rate what can be only a rental.
2009- Sanchez B.( poor stats but still makes it happen). Greene B-.
2008- Keller C+. (still hasn't lived up to the hype,on the fringe)
2007- Revis A+. (nuff said). Harris A-.
2006- Brick A. Mangold A+. Leon B+( ST's) B Smith B+.
2005- Rhodes A. (back to his old self) Pouha C+.
2009- Nicks A. Beatty C+.
2008- K Phillips B- (injuries)
2007- Ross C. (hasn't lived up to 1st rd status). SS12 A. Boss B-. Bradshaw A..
2006- Kiwi B-(injuries). Cofield A-.
2005- Tuck A+ C Web B+ B Jacobs A-. (back to form this yr.)
Both teams use their methods well. JETS seem to have more bust but more top tear talent. What do you think?