Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Devils Beat Rangers, Head To Stanley Cup Finals

Shifting the Blame

New York fans are famous for dramatizing every game. In this town, meaningless victorious are praised like championships and losing is equivalent to sinning. With every loss, we as Jets fans find it necessary to pick a scapegoat. While I don't agree with this philosophy, I will admit that the loss against the Broncos was alarming. I won't even mention Brian Schottenheimer's short comings, because they have been analyzed to exhaustion. Instead, I believe that the blame should be placed on Mike Tannenbaum.

Star-divide

 

Since assuming his position in 2006, Mike Tannenbaum has repeatedly proven that he's a better general manager than the fans at home. Every one of his decisions has been criticized on this site (and other forums), but a very high percentage of them have worked out for the better. I love his wheel-and-deal approach, and I consider him among the top GM's in the league. With that being said, Mike T. has made serious errors this year, and these mishaps threaten to destroy the season. 

In my opinion, the Jets had two glaring weaknesses coming into the season: a lack of a pass rush and shallow depth on the offensive line. The latter weakness was further aggravated by Rob Turner's preseason injury. We didn't need to acquire any superstars, just some role players that fit the needs. Money was not an issue, as Tannenbaum deftly freed up millions in preparation for the Nnamdi Asomugha sweepstakes. Available talent wasn't an issue either, as several serviceable veterans were cut during training camp. In fact, the (6-3) Ravens picked up Bryant McKinnie and Andre Gurode late in the preseason. McKinnie has become the starter at LT, and Gurode is the primary backup on the line, already filling in for five games. The Ravens have been above average protecting their QB despite having two "fill-ins" on the line (13th best in the NFL with 20 sacks allowed. The Jets are 26th in the league with 26 sacks allowed). Picking up one of these guys as a backup would have solidified a line that currently employs Vlad "The Impaler" Ducasse as their main backup. If any lineman goes down, we can pretty much call the season in. As for the pass rush, there was a myriad of options. Matt Roth isn't a world-beater, but he'd be valuable as a pass-rusher in a rotation of linemen that don't get much pressure on the quarterback (3 total sacks). Admittedly, "Mr. T" caught lightning in a bottle with Aaron Maybin, but clearly it hasn't been enough to alleviate this problem.

Tannenbaum has become known for his big trades, improving the team by taking chances on risk/reward guys like Santonio Holmes, Braylon Edwards, and Antonio Cromartie. This September, he traded safety Dwight Lowery for an unconditional draft pick, which created a third weakness: a lack of a cover safety. Eric Smith isn't a bad football player, he's just horrible in coverage. I'm not saying that Dwight Lowery would have neutralized tight ends Jason Witten, Rob Gronkowski, or Antonio Gates, but he certainly could have helped. Why did Tannenbaum trade our best cover safety? That is certainly beyond me.

From a fan's perspective, it certainly appears as if Mike Tannenbaum stockpiled his chips in anticipation of a big move (i.e.- Nnamdi Asomugha), and was taken off guard when none of these moves materialized. He went for the home run when all the Jets needed was a single. If the Jets have a successful year, it will be in spite of Mike Tannenbaum's moves, not because of them. 

Comment 37 comments  |  1 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

More from Gang Green Nation

Flight Connections 05-26-12

May 2012 by dvdvil - 2 comments

Flight Connections 05-25-12

May 2012 by dvdvil - 11 comments

Flight Connections 05-24-12

May 2012 by dvdvil - 17 comments

Flight Connections 05-23-12

May 2012 by dvdvil - 11 comments

Flight Connections 05-21-12

May 2012 by dvdvil - 10 comments

Comments

Display:

Knew it was a matter of time we got a well written article on this fact, Great Job!

It’s definitely something that too many people over look. We are handcuffed from the top down. Woody not wanting to spend that 8 Mil in cap space, Tanny not addressing line depth issues but resigning Wayne Hunter as a starter, the coaches not knowing any other the strengths or weakness of their players, and key starters executing whenever they see fit. Top to bottom mediocrity.

by Timmaht on Nov 18, 2011 4:30 PM EST reply actions  

Nice Read man.

I’m definitely sold on this.

GANG GREEN ALL DAY!
I put God first! Anything else comes a distant second, next to a cross-country third.
Being that I'm Nigerian, being a Jets' Fan only comes natural... it's all about that old Green and White.
You see, it's not about how you won the game, it's about how you played the game.... there's a difference. If you don't understand this, then you're losing big time.

by King A! on Nov 18, 2011 5:04 PM EST reply actions  

Good read.

shed the light. Tanny is great but he stunk up the offseason. He allowed Cotchery to leave because Cotchery said so, the o-line depth is crap,and we still dont have a pass rushing threat. Hopefully he realizes that we have no OC, and sancez cant excel with Brian Schottenhiemer gamplanning.

by jets4life24 on Nov 18, 2011 5:19 PM EST reply actions  

You can’t blame Tannenbaum for personnel moves (or lack thereof) that are clearly influenced by his head coach. Mike T wasn’t in love with Aso, Rex was. And the reason we have no pass rush is because Rex thinks his blitzes provide enough pressure that pass rushers aren’t important.

Look at the drafts we had under Mangini. Funny how Tanny looked like a freakin’ mastermind then. But he’s just the financial wizard who facilitates the contracts and trade arrangements his head coach wants done. And in that capacity, he’s outstanding IMO

by nationalist88 on Nov 18, 2011 5:23 PM EST reply actions  

Don't get me wrong, Tannenbaum is great

But as far as just working to Rex’s wishes, I highly doubt that Rex told him not to get an experienced backup for the OL. Maybe there was something unreported that was going on behind the scenes with Lowery, and Rex wanted him gone (like Derrick Mason), but I haven’t heard anything like that so this trade baffled me.

If you come to a fork in the road, take it.-Yogi Berra
Staff Writer on GangGreenNation.com

by Jeff W. on Nov 18, 2011 5:41 PM EST up reply actions  

Think about Tanny’s backround, and this is the point everyone’s missing; he worked strictly as a cap specialist under Parcells. He’s not a football mind, he’s a numbers guy. His input regarding who we should get or who we should release has to be limited at best. I have to believe that the Jets’ HC places the order, and it’s Mike T’s job to get on the phone with the agents and fill it.

by nationalist88 on Nov 18, 2011 9:19 PM EST up reply actions  

I agree that Lowery was a bad move

nut honestly Mike T has two problems: Our expectations are ridiculously high and regression was bound to happen eventually, you can’t get cheap big name players every year.

The other problem is Woody Johnson tightening his check book. Every non-signing or FA that walked away was allegedly due to financial reasons according to Rex and Mike. We still have a healthy amount of $$$ on hand that never went to Nnamdi. The bottom line is since before the CBA Woody and several other owners have been scaling back expenses. I can’t count the number of times this offseason where Tanny said something along the lines of “I’d like to but my hands are tied financially”. With plenty of cap space left, who do you think is doing the tying?

Arm chair GM. Mod/contributing writer at SBN Jets blog GGN.
GangGreenNation.com

by Bro Namath on Nov 18, 2011 5:23 PM EST reply actions  

Very interesting
Our expectations are ridiculously high and regression was bound to happen eventually, you can’t get cheap big name players every year.

Thats interesting, I never thought of it that way. I guess we did buy into the Tannenbaum hype. He was great the first few years, but maybe he was overachieving. I sure hope not.

We still have a healthy amount of $$$ on hand that never went to Nnamdi.

That’s the thing. Mike T was able to convince Woody that Aso would make sense, and the Jets made a very healthy offer. I have heard that Woody is trying to cut back a little (as you said), but I assume that Woody approved that offer? Why couldn’t Mike use that approved $$$ to make less glamorous moves?

If you come to a fork in the road, take it.-Yogi Berra
Staff Writer on GangGreenNation.com

by Jeff W. on Nov 18, 2011 5:32 PM EST up reply actions  

From what I understand

The reason we didn’t offer Nnamdi more is the team was afraid of what Team Revis would do if another corner on the same team got a bigger contract.

Editor-In-Chief
Gang Green Nation
SB Nation's Jets Blog
http://www.ganggreennation.com

by John B on Nov 18, 2011 6:06 PM EST via mobile up reply actions  

Myunderstanding is that Nnamdi go a contract well stort of Revis's and

what the Eagles paid was millions short of what Revis is making now, no?

by Timmaht on Nov 18, 2011 7:33 PM EST up reply actions  

I believe higher than what the Jets were offering, though.

Editor-In-Chief
Gang Green Nation
SB Nation's Jets Blog
http://www.ganggreennation.com

by John B on Nov 18, 2011 8:06 PM EST up reply actions  

Oh, yeah for sure, but just a tad more. With the cap space we had, we could have got him.

For better or worse and Revis wouldn’t have been jealous as he’d be paid more and be shown as much better. Heck, for the money we have, we could have signed Cro and moved Nnamdi back to his original position of safety (Where he was terrible).

by Timmaht on Nov 18, 2011 10:02 PM EST up reply actions  

He should sign Braylon back

Its was just something about him last year that gave me confidence in our offense. Like they would eventually make a big play because he could make some pretty athletic catches. I dont get that same feeling with Plaxico

"Some things you just can't question. Like you can't question why two plus two is four. So don't question it, don't try to look it up. I don't know who made it, all I know is it was put in my head that two plus two is four. So certain things happen. Why does it rain? Why am I so sexy? I don't know." - Shaquille O'Neal

by CinnamonToastCrunch on Nov 18, 2011 6:25 PM EST reply actions  

Braylon should never have been let go.

He sure made Sanchez look better because he could stretch the field. Our offense has gotta be a dream to defend now that the deep ball is absolutely non-existent.

by nationalist88 on Nov 18, 2011 9:13 PM EST up reply actions  

Completely agree in regards to OL

I have long said that if indeed this season rested on the QB making a leap, not bolstering the OL is criminal. Nothing is perhaps more important than the OL, yet for more than one year Tannenbaum has taken the approach that OL is a position that is “cheap”, something you can just mix and fill. The OL is the soul of the offense. The OL is what makes the run game go (which is key to the play-action) and the OL is what give the QB 3.5 seconds instead of 2.7 seconds (which is an eternity of a difference.

As far as the pass rusher, that is not really so much on Mr. T, I think. It is Rex’s experiment that a team can avoid the big ticket pass rusher (and that chunk out of the cap) by building through blitz scheme and DBs. It is a basic philosophical premise that Rex brought. It is just for that reason that we gave the bank instead to Revis, and paired him with Cro, and drafted Wilson. Now though that the league has adapted to Rex’s exotic blitzes, it seems that the entire cap strategy on defense is in jeopardy. We are now stuck with smaller, slower safeties are are getting exposed in coverage schemes, especially now that we no longer bring the fort.

by ________key on Nov 18, 2011 6:53 PM EST reply actions  

Can't really knock him on the OL either, though.

I’m sure in private conversations that Callahan said that Hunter was solid and Ducasse would develop to be much further along than now. Their under performance along with Turner going to the IR made things much bleaker than Tanny had any reason to anticipate.

Up to this point, Callahan was a wizard and Tanny had no reason to question his assessments of Hunter and Ducasse. Especially if Rex and Schotty concur.

Ducasse’s inability to play himself into the RT spot is the biggest reason for the OL taking a step back. This is a kid they snatched in the 2nd round that they claimed had a first round grade. He should not only be starting by now, but he should be playing at a higher level than Hunter is right now. That swing and miss has set this team back so far, I think.

by Crackback on Nov 19, 2011 4:03 PM EST up reply actions  

I’m sure in private conversations that Callahan said that Hunter was solid and Ducasse would develop to be much further along than now.

Why are you sure of that?

by ________key on Nov 19, 2011 7:41 PM EST up reply actions  

It seems pretty clear to me that Tannenbaum has taken the...

“Offensive line is cheap” approach.

First he unceremoniously kicked pro-bowler Alan Faneca off and seemed to have filled the position cheaper with Slauson. Then he let go of Woody surely feeling he was about to do the same thing. Cap setting is all about finding bargains as positions x, y, z so you can spend for difference makes at positions a, b, c. Tannenbaum has taken the approach that you can borrow from the OL (which has to not just be “good”, it has to excel) in order to pad other more supposedly “important” positions.

by ________key on Nov 19, 2011 7:53 PM EST up reply actions  

Finally!!

Absolutely 100% right! I think Tanny is decent, but I think a shortcoming of his is his ego…he loves his name in the headlines for making big deals. He completely neglected the pass rush and O-line for Asomugha….when we already have the best cornerback tandem in the league! Even if Rex was pushing it, Tanny has final say so on personnel moves so he should take the blame here. To have no pass rush (and we really don’t…I think Maybin’s 15 minutes are just about up) in the NFL is nonsense. To neglect your O-line to the point that your young, developing “franchise” QB takes a beating worse than Rocky every week is madness. Asomugha was a complete waste of time and hurt the team overall. At least Plax got Tanny his headlines.

He also hurt Sanchez with his WR moves. In three years, a developing QB has to throw to an almost completely different set of receivers each year. That is insane…how does he develop consistency (much less confidence) with that? Getting rid of Edwards was a mistake. I know he’s not having a great year, but he’s in a new system with a new QB. I think Sanchez was getting comfortable with Edwards and he played well for us. No reason to let him go. Same with J-Co…Mason was such a disaster and the Jets lost a good leader, fan favorite and Sanchez’s favorite target. Man, the more I write this, the worse Tanny looks.

by O-Insanity on Nov 18, 2011 7:14 PM EST reply actions  

if you were going to undermine a QB you couldn’t come up with a better plan.

1. weaken the OL
2. change his receiver corps
3. make him throw lots of throws he isn’t strong in

The only thing missing is 4. give him a new OC (which probably would have been the best thing).

by ________key on Nov 18, 2011 7:26 PM EST up reply actions  

O-line I agree with.

Big ticket pass rushers do not grow on trees. Especially 3-4 OLB pass rushers (which is what would be required in this defense). I can go along with not being in love with the Hunter contract/philosophy, and the continual changes in the WR core, as well as the fact that he has been decent but not stellar as a drafter (with a trade up philosophy that I don’t love). Overall his moves have worked out better than I thought they would at the times they were made. Tannenbaum is a pretty good GM, but not a great one.

by Buzzy on Nov 18, 2011 7:30 PM EST reply actions  

Good points

I mentioned Bryant Mckinnie in a post I did earlier. I think about that guy everytime Sanchez gets pegged in the spine by a defensive end. I think the move for Dwight Lowery might have been for Lowery as well as the Jets. Rex said that he had an opportunity to go somewhere and maybe start, and they wanted to give him the chance. I believe that. Another thing is at the time there was Brodney Poole, Eric Smith, and Jim Leonhard and Lowery is in the last year of his contract. Jets get a draft pick for a guy they probably couldn’t resign next year.

by manuvsteal on Nov 18, 2011 9:10 PM EST reply actions  

Nice job on the write up

Tanny has not had a great year but i think there are more factors. The first being that Woody Johnson seemed to get a bit cheap. You send an awful message to the players when you treat a leader and lifetime Jet like Ellis the way they did.

As far as needing a pass rusher, one would think the defensive genius who coaches our team wouldve developed one by year three. I also think Tanny had faith in Callahan to develop the guys who would eventually be replacements on the O Line.

If it is true that Rex has a major influence on who comes and goes and who is drafted, I have to say he pales in comparison to Mangini when it comes to evaluating talent. With all this said, Im not ready to dump Tanny, I have not forgotten the Terry Bradway years.

Should you choose to test my resolve in this matter, you will be facing a finality beyond your comprehension, and you will not be counting days, or months, or years, but milleniums in a place with no doors.

by YankeesJets on Nov 18, 2011 10:35 PM EST reply actions  

Please, don't take it the wrong way
With all this said, Im not ready to dump Tanny, I have not forgotten the Terry Bradway years.

I would never want to see Tanny get fired. He’s done a great job here. His entire body of work is unquestionable, its just this offseason that I’m questioning. By the way, even this year wasn’t all bad. He chose Holmes over Braylon (good choice), Plax over Braylon (arguable, but I don’t mind it), and went younger on the D-line (so far so good). His draft was very good too (Mo Wilk, Kenrick Ellis, Jeremy Kerley are all contributing already). Not too bad, but he completely disregarded the glaring needs.

I also think Tanny had faith in Callahan to develop the guys who would eventually be replacements on the O Line.

By late August (when Gurode and McKinnie became available), it was painfully obvious to everyone that Vlad Ducasse was not a capable backup, at least not yet.

If you come to a fork in the road, take it.-Yogi Berra
Staff Writer on GangGreenNation.com

by Jeff W. on Nov 19, 2011 12:43 AM EST up reply actions  

i dissagree w/ plax over braylon . bad timing for chez , being hes’ only going into his 3rd year and so needing to gel with his recievers . it was like starting over as a rookie and in a perfect world ( solid o-line ) he’dve been ok . but he needed the consistancy of holmes, braylon and keller . ,…….if you can picture plax in the huddle w/ chez , plax is staring him down every step of the way , when it should be the other way around . mark doesnt have total control of this offense . and thats not a good thing . factor in the descision making of shotty , constantly throwing underneath when 6’5’ should be going for jump balls on the sidelines all day . braylon made plays and you dont give up much , you take away from the ‘team’ thing .

by g86jn on Nov 19, 2011 8:42 AM EST up reply actions  

I go back and forth on the Plax vs. Braylon debate

Sanchez and Braylon definitely were on the same page, as evidenced by Braylon’s big catches in the clutch moments last season. Also, he provided a deep threat that the Jets are sorely lacking in right now. However, Plax’s height is undeniable, and the Jets have went from being a horrible red zone team to being a very good red zone team. Is that all because of Plax? Probably not, but I think he plays a large role in that. Also, the whole whole debate might be moot, because Braylon wasn’t willing to accept the contract that the Jets could afford. He eventually settled for a similar one with the 49ers, but it appeared that he was seriously insulted that his own team (the Jets) didn’t think higher of him.

If you come to a fork in the road, take it.-Yogi Berra
Staff Writer on GangGreenNation.com

by Jeff W. on Nov 19, 2011 12:03 PM EST up reply actions  

I agree with Braylon for feeling insulted

Im not sure why Tanny, Woody Johnson, and Rex felt the need to jettison so many of the guys that helped get us to the title games. I understood the reason to grab Plax(Red Zone Threat) but this team was pretty much a run stopper away from the SB, yet they lost let guys like Dig, Lowery, and Ellis go. I know not every player can be retained but outside of Smith and possibly Braylon, I cant see how these other guys couldnt have been brought back.

Should you choose to test my resolve in this matter, you will be facing a finality beyond your comprehension, and you will not be counting days, or months, or years, but milleniums in a place with no doors.

by YankeesJets on Nov 19, 2011 3:55 PM EST up reply actions  

I disagree, Tannenbaum doesn't play football, never has. He doesn't scout or strategize.

Rex guaranteed that THIS team would win the Superbowl. Not we’ll win it, if Tannebaum would finally get me a OT, OLB and a safety.

by Clarke W. Griswald on Nov 18, 2011 11:14 PM EST reply actions  

The thing is, the lack of a OT, OLB and safety was painfully obvious to everyone.

Every armchair GM on this site was saying it. Every talking head on TV was saying it. It should’ve been done, regardless of what Rex says. Its true that Tanny isn’t really a football guy, more of a numbers guy, but it didn’t take a genius to figure it out.

If you come to a fork in the road, take it.-Yogi Berra
Staff Writer on GangGreenNation.com

by Jeff W. on Nov 19, 2011 12:48 AM EST up reply actions  

Bronco fan again, again not here to gloat

There wasn’t a pass rush because most of the game your defense was in an oversized personnel to combat our run game. There were many times where your D-line had the three biggest lineman on your team plus bigger linebackers——I really didn’t notice Maybin being out there a lot. Plus in the final drive, our offense spread you out with a 3WR/2TE empty set look and I really only noticed four rushing the majority of the time, there were a few plays where blitzes were brought including the final play.

But as to your other complaint, I watched the Jets/Ravens game and without your starting C it was absolutely horrific, the Ravens D just lit the middle of that line up and terrorized Sanchez all game. Our pass rush is excellent as well, mostly from the edges depending on what D. Allen has dialed up. But on your last drive, Von Miller absolutely lit up your RT and shoved him to the ground before sacking Sanchez. So I would definitely agree that better O-line depth is a need—-though to be fair to whoever that was Von Miller is an absolute beast!

What do you think of Vlad Ducasse? Is he a full-time starter now, or a spot player? I remember wanted the Broncos to draft him when he came out, how is he doing?

by Bronco Mike on Nov 19, 2011 8:02 AM EST reply actions  

they dont give vlad too much time but i see him making plays on special teams . ,…you had a good read on the game , and until i heard millers a runner up for rookie mvp , i never seen him play . hes’ fast has long arms and looks hungry every play . he should be great for a long time .

by g86jn on Nov 19, 2011 8:53 AM EST up reply actions  

Taking nothing for Von Miller

Everybody eats up the Jets RT. We call him the human turnstile. He was a backup last season played a few good games when Damien Woody got hurt so the coaches forced Woody to retire and put their QB life in the turnstile hands. Great job Rex.

by BIG OH!!!!! on Nov 19, 2011 10:45 AM EST up reply actions  

Vlad Ducasse is a project. I kinda fear that he'll always remain a project, never devolping into a serviceable starter

As far as Wayne Hunter goes, a lot of people are down on him because he started the season horribly. He’s gotten a lot better, playing at a high level until the Denver game. I don’t really blame him for losing the battle to Von Miller, this kid looks like he should’ve been double teamed every single time.

If you come to a fork in the road, take it.-Yogi Berra
Staff Writer on GangGreenNation.com

by Jeff W. on Nov 19, 2011 12:00 PM EST up reply actions  

Tanny and the OL

In terms of Ducasse, what most are forgetting is that there was no real off season which is the prime time for 2nd year players. Additionally, Ducasse is from a small school, so if anyone needs that off season coaching it would be him. NOTE: he still has the best size/ agility ratio of any of our lineman. You draft on potential, and VLAD has tremendous potential at an area of need, so you can’t bame Tanny just yet. Not everyone comes out gangbusters, we have to DEVELOP our players and thats what coaches get paid lots of money to do. A fair judgement of Ducasse will have to wait until the end of training camp 2012. As for Hunter, he has had flashes and is more than capable Athletically to defend against anyone. The problem for him is consistency. He plays well for 90% but then has a lapse. Those 10% of the plays that he gets beat, he gets REALLY BEAT and could get Sanchez killed. He’s a wild card. Tanny took a gamble and right now it looks like a bad one. HUnter has never played 16 games before so lets see what happens these next 6 games, but right now he gets a D. Next year VLAD should beat hunter out OR maybe we spend another high draft pick on a RT, maybe get a veteran in FA then let the best man win. Loser provides excellent depth. ( Also HUnter returns and will help at every position on the line). However, What is really troubling is the entire line has looked poor, including Mangold who we know is not 100%. Fergie has given up 3-4 sacks this year already, thats more than he gave up all last year, Slauson is just OK and Moore is 31, maybe we need a guard in the draft’s 1st 3 rounds. Crazy how a strength has all of a sudden become a liability.

On another note, hard to judge Sanchez when he’s getting blasted 10 times a game.

And yes Mckinnie would have been a help

by Jet Set on Nov 20, 2011 5:10 PM EST reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about the New York Jets.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Rackmultipart
GGN Thread About Nothing #18 Enter Sandman
545595_428600250485671_100000070982458_1739202_129649609_n_1_small
5 players that i expect to see improvement from this year
P3733056reg_small
Why will Aaron Maybin get 10-20 sacks this season.
Small
Do You Trust The Jets' Front Office?
Small
Diggin Dunbar Diggin the 46

Recent FanPosts

Small
Will G&P Be Back in 2012?
P3733056reg_small
My Life as a New York Jets Fan.
Small
Conner can run
Small
Thoughts on the upcoming season part 1: What to watch for
Small
Thoughts On the Upcoming Season Part 2: The season
Small
Thoughts On the Upcoming Season Part 3: Cleaning House
Small
The Peyton-Goes-Down Debacle Prequel, and the Best QB Some of You Never Heard Of.

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


Managing Editors

Gangreen-large_small John B

Great-british-events-flag_small David_Wyatt

Staff Writers

Revis_island_small Bro Namath

943_small dvdvil

Wayne_chrebet1_small GangGreenMag

Haters_small bobdolethesnapplelady

Santana_moss_small Jeff W.

Moderators

Revis_christ_small Judgegavel

Return_of_the_jet-i_small MachlinT

Jimmy2_small Tamarack

Rackmultipart rexthejet