Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Dana White: Carlos Condit Accepts Rematch With Nick Diaz

What Do You Think of an 18 Game Regular Season?

A hot topic going around the league right now is the potential for the regular season schedule to increase to 18 games. The NFL would shorten the preseason to 2 games in this scenario. Fans have differening opinions on it. I think it is a great idea.

Preseason is meaningless. By far the most important development for teams is avoiding injury. Today's athlete trains year round. The players are not playing themselves into shape during preseason. They are already in shape. Fans going to the stadium still have to pay regular season prices, though.

An expanded regular season means more football. It gives the league more flexibility to create interesting matchups. Instead of playing every preseason in a game meaningless to everybody not named Brandon Jacobs, the Jets and Giants could meet every year in a game that matters. The NFL could produce a Super Bowl rematch. They could produce a rematch of Playoff games. Under the current system, these things could only happen by chance. The schedule is locked. Teams play 6 games in the division, 4 against a division in conference rotating each year, 4 against a division in the other conference rotating each year, and 2 against the teams from the other teams in conference that finished in the same spot in the standings the year before. Throw in an extra pair of games, and the league could give us the matchups we want to see. It also would mean we would get to enjoy the league for an additional pair of weekends each year.

Some argue there would be greater potential for injuries. There is some validity to this point, but it was also true when the league went from 14 to 16 games. Nobody is suggesting the NFL cuts back to 14 again. There are also ways around it. The NFL could expand rosters to give teams a chance to keep players fresher. At the very least, the final cutdown to 53 men could come after the first few weeks of the season. The league could also add a short term disabled list like baseball, which would allow a team to replace an injured player on the roster until said player returns (I think this should happen even if the schedule does not expand).

Some might argue the league should just cut back the preseason games without adding to the regular season. This idea has some validity, but I'm not sure how realistic it is. Will teams really agree to reducing the number of revenue producing dates on the schedule?

What are your thoughts?

Poll
What should the NFL do with its regular season?
Make it 18 games
116 votes
Keep it at 16 games
162 votes

278 votes | Poll has closed

Comment 19 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

I would prefer to keep it at 16

I don’t know how much the injury rate increased after the jump from 14 games to 16 games, but I would imagine that every increase in games would affect injury rates by an exponential factor rather than a linear one since you’re more likely to become injured the longer you play. I think this would lead to a lot of crappier players being thrown into games out of necessity, which would bring down the quality of play.

It’s not really that important, but I would also be annoyed at a lot of single-season records getting broken, if not shattered, due to this, like any record related to passing and receiving I would imagine, both offensively and defensively. I’m a stat geek so that would bother me, but it’s not really a big deal in the grand scheme of things.

But even still… it’s not like I’d be sad if there was an 18 game season! MORE FOOTBALLLLLL

by Exystence on Aug 27, 2010 9:42 AM EDT reply actions  

The biggest difference is that you’ll have starters playing 2 more games a year (not to mention playoffs) and the 3rd string would probably not exist since you really only have 2 games to showcase them. You’d have to expect more injuries and perhaps even lose a year off a player’s total career due to increased touches and fatigue. I think if you expect starters to play more games you need to:

1. Increase to 18 games
2. Increase the roster to 56 to allow for more substituting (to keep guys fresher, longer into the season)
3. Increase salary cap to allow for the extra 3 players and pay some of the key guys extra for going 2 more games.
4. Increase the size of the practice squad to 10 from 8 to allow for more unknown players to “stick around” in the nfl since their skills wont be demonstrated as easily as they can in a preseason game.
5. think about adding a second bye week to allow banged up players to heal, and maybe try to avoid super short weeks (those thursday night games are killer if you just played on Sunday night the week prior).

http://www.charlottejetsfans.com

by NC_Scott on Aug 27, 2010 12:58 PM EDT up reply actions  

An idea to replace preseason with an Olympics like feel

Another idea, if you are eliminating the preseason (or most of it) is to do a nfl playoff style tourny in June featuring UFAs, rookies, backups and practice squad players. Only people allowed to play are those that played in <9 NFL games. Teams send their backups and coaches to the tourny and the winner gets another 2nd round pick at the end of the next draft. It would take 5 weeks to play out and the best team will have the most promising talent, not the biggest all-stars meaning that a crappy team like Cleveland might win if they have a better bench than the others. Bring all teams to a different city each year, like Los Angeles or Vegas or Charleston, or Syracuse or Salt Lake City, and hold the events fri night, sat 1, sat 2, sat night, sun 1, sun 2,sun night and mon night so you can get 8 games or more in per venue. Families can travel to that city like the olympics to watch the tourny for a weekend or longer, and doing it in June means better weather, more fans (on vacation) and you can keep costs low.

Jets would send players like QB O’Connell, RBs McKnight, Woodhead, Washington, Conner, WRs Clowney, Henry, Taylor, TEs Cumberland, Mulligan, OLs Ducasse, Slauson, Felix, Turner, Hunter, and some of the UDFAs on offense. Same idea on D.

http://www.charlottejetsfans.com

by NC_Scott on Aug 27, 2010 1:01 PM EDT up reply actions  

The question should really be, “What do you think of a leaguewide work stoppage?” because that’s our only alternative.

http://www.jetskvetch.com
Come join me as I fanatically follow the goys in green!

by Max VV on Aug 27, 2010 9:44 AM EDT reply actions  

I think they should keep it at 16 and add an extra bye week for each team. This way players can rest and be fresher later in the season and the NFL can make more money by having one more Sunday Night and Monday Night football games. Everyone would win with 18 weeks of football, potentially few injuries and more money for the owners

by jfjets16 on Aug 27, 2010 9:52 AM EDT reply actions  

+1

Good idea! I also believe if you cut down to two pre-season games that gives rookies & UDFA less of an opportunity to make a team.

by NYC KID on Aug 27, 2010 11:52 AM EDT up reply actions  

Am I just me?

Or wasn’t the league already scratching its head about making the last few games in the schedule more interesting? Isn’t it why they’ve made the teams go against division rivals this year? I thought it was a big problem making all 16 games matter. Now they want to add two more?

I think this will end up as a big flop like the experiment wih playing the Bills in Toronto.

and the home of the... JETS!!!
www.ganggreennation.com
If you're not part of the solution, you're part of the precipitate.

by dvdvil on Aug 27, 2010 9:56 AM EDT reply actions  

I like it the way it is. But having an 18-game season may be the best way to have a season at all next year. If that’s the case, than im all for it, but if theres an alternative, id prefer we avoid using this.

Contributing Writer - GangGreenNation.com
Marty Brodeur - Stealing Rangers' lunch money since 1990

by Ryan Alfieri on Aug 27, 2010 10:18 AM EDT reply actions  

18 is too much

I am itching for football as much as the next guy right now. So my gut reaction to this question is an 18 game season. But I watch college football as well, and come January/February of every year I am pretty much at my capacity of watching football for a few months.

We should really be asking this question after the super bowl. At that time of year does anyone really feel the season would have been improved if 2 addition regular season games were included? Fans of bubble teams probably would, but I expect that would be the extent of it.

Therefore, I prefer a 16 game schedule.

by JetGreen on Aug 27, 2010 10:45 AM EDT reply actions  

18 is too much

Also I heard if the league expanded to 18 games, the season would actually move back. They wouldn’t start the season until mid-September and end the year in March.

"It ain't over till it's over." - Yogi Berra

by KSJ49 on Aug 27, 2010 11:15 AM EDT reply actions  

Agree 18 is too much

Too many pointless games in the last 2-3 weeks of the season already.

I have to for once agree with MJD over at yahoo. If they really want to do this for the fans, why don’t they just stop charging full price for preseason games? Or stop forcing season ticket holders to buy pre-season tickets as part of the package. Or any of the other ways that the owners gouge the fans.

18 game seasons only help the owners get richer. In reality more players are going to get hurt and increase the chances that the playoffs will be nothing more then the Healthiest team moves on.

If the 4 game preseason is useless, then cut it to 2. There’s no reason to go and add 2 games to the regular season.

Dominik signed me for 20 years, and all I got was a press conference and a voided contract...
Contributor to Lighthouse Hockey not sure if I'm the Sniper or the Enforcer.

by Mark D on Aug 27, 2010 11:35 AM EDT reply actions  

Too Many Warm Weather Games

I am a traditionalist. Football is a winter sport. The proposal is to make the last two preseason games regular season games. That would effectively make 3/4 of the games being played in warm weather. I prefer cold weather, hard hitting, run oriented football. I think this would give way too much of a regular season advantage to the teams that play in the heat, the Dolphins, Charges,Cardinals, Bucs, Jags etc.. Not to mention the all girl teams that play in domes. The great equalizer has always been when the weather gets cold and these teams have to travel up North. This proposal would take away that balance and change the game. I was at the Jets/Dolphins game in Miami last year and I saw the Jets defense droop in the heat and humidity (it was a night game, but it was still brutal). Being accustomed to playing in those conditions is a huge advantage. Then again, I would ban domed stadiums, so take it for what it’s worth.

by USA on Aug 27, 2010 12:02 PM EDT reply actions  

Im reading a lot of comments about the end of the season being watered down.

I dont think that has anything to do with the number or games as much as it has to do with poor scheduling. If teams were playng their division rivals more often in the last few weeks of the season it wouldnt matter if they had to play 20 games. Lets say the last 3 weeks of the season were dedicated to loading up on divisional games. Example: If the colts had to play the texans and titans in week 16 and 18 the last 3 games of their season become too important to sit their starters at least untill the game is way out of hand. The potential swing in the standings could cost a team home field advantage or even a spot in the playoffs all together.
Lets talk about injuries.
If fans or players are concerned about injuries. Well thats fine but this league has expanded before and players have adapted. And they would have to adapt again We have no idea what the physical limit of a NFL player is so none of us can say when were asking to much of them. And if teams make a case for keeping a few more players on their roster. What is the real problem with that? Teams would love to have a chance to keep some extra skill players in case of injury. Mabye last year this team could have kept Woodhead on the roster. Fans would have been all for that. Danny’s a cult hero after his showing in the preseason last year. And Im sure every camp in the NFL has stories just like his.
     One last thing. I hate commenting on money. Its too subjective. So I wont even bother with the players salaries and if they need to increase because they are playing more games. However Im sure season ticket holders would be more inclined to spend their money on more games that mean something instead of a boring 4th preseason game.

by colinyoung on Aug 27, 2010 12:54 PM EDT reply actions  

I wish they would cut one preseason game

The 4th one is always pointless, but the first 3 are used well. But that would lead to an odd-numbered regular season, which I don’t think exists in sports. Oh well.

I support whatever the players support. They’re the ones who play the game, after all. The players should have a much larger voice than they do now.

Is it NFL time yet?

by Grady90 on Aug 27, 2010 1:15 PM EDT reply actions  

If there were only three games, then teams would just rest starters on Game 3 and probably play them more on Game 2.

and the home of the... JETS!!!
www.ganggreennation.com
If you're not part of the solution, you're part of the precipitate.

by dvdvil on Aug 27, 2010 2:20 PM EDT up reply actions  

18 games!!!

More football = more fun

Increase the rosters.
Injuries are not my problem, i want football.
Preseason sucks. Get rid of it. Let teams do intersquad scrimmages and have one exhibition game.

I love the Marqui Match-ups idea. Give the fans the game they want to see.

by Crackback on Aug 27, 2010 2:03 PM EDT reply actions  

How about...

We worry about the issue at hand first? Like, um… the CBA and potential LOCKOUT?! Deal with that shit FIRST and then worry about extending the friggin season. Jackasses. (not you guys, the owners.)

by umohan21 on Aug 27, 2010 10:24 PM EDT reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about the New York Jets.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Small
New Weekly FanPost Idea:
058_sione_pouha--300x300_small
Weekly Caption Contest (no, this has nothing to do with fanshots) Week #1
Revis_island_small
Bro Namath Needs Your Help (Unrec please)
Small
The Natural
058_sione_pouha--300x300_small
What is a Fanshot, and why you should care (Plus MS Paint). (unrec the sucker because we need to shorten the reccomended posts)

Recent FanPosts

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


Managing Editors

Gangreen-large_small John B

Great-british-events-flag_small David_Wyatt

Staff Writers

Revis_island_small Bro Namath

943_small dvdvil

Wayne_chrebet1_small GangGreenMag

Haters_small bobdolethesnapplelady

Santana_moss_small Jeff W.

Moderators

Revis_christ_small Judgegavel

Return_of_the_jet-i_small MachlinT

Jets_small Tamarack

058_sione_pouha--300x300_small rexthejet