Gang Green Nation Speaks With Football Outsiders
Bill Barnwell of the popular statistical website Football Outsiders just released his new book to preview the upcoming season, Football Outsiders Almanac 2010. It is available for $21.95 on Amazon.com.
Bill was kind enough to answer a few questions pertaining to the chapter he wrote on the Jets.
John B: You note that in a vacuum teams with pass defenses as good as the Jets had last year tend to regress. How much do you think the additions of Antonio Cromartie and Kyle Wilson to the secondary, guys who appear to fit the system well, can help mitigate that?
Bill Barnwell: Well, I think there are issues with each. Cromartie just hasn't been very effective as a pro cornerback outside of his one year with the 10 picks, and he has injury issues going back through college. Wilson's definitely a talented player, but he's a rookie; rookie cornerbacks really tend to struggle before maturing. Honestly, I think that they'll both look better across from Darrelle Revis, but I think any cornerback fits the system of playing across from Revis.
JB: You mention what Mark Sanchez did as a rookie resembles quite a range of rookie years from JaMarcus Russell and Ryan Leaf to Troy Aikman and Peyton Manning. Is there any sort of way to model how a quarterback will progress after his first year, or is it a crapshoot? What is your best guess on the kind of second year Sanchez will have?
BB: I think Sanchez presents such a unique situation that it's really hard to project his performance. Last year, we took a lot of flak for noting that Sanchez's stats were similar to the stats of JaMarcus Russell at the same age (in his second season). It's even worse you can consider that Sanchez had a far better running game around him and more weapons than Russell did. On the other hand, though, Sanchez is unlike most any quarterback of recent vintage; he barely played at USC, was really good when he did, and is obviously still learning at the pro level.
I would say that the range of quarterbacks Sanchez can be is still so wide that it's impossible to say what sort of player he'll end up being. This year, you'd expect a decline in his interception rate and an increase in his yards per attempt, since he has so many downfield weapons. I wonder if the expected injuries on the offensive line will increase his sack rate, though.
JB: How do you think the return of Kris Jenkins from injury will impact the Jets?
BB: I was really expecting their rush defense to decline when Jenkins went down, but it stayed exactly the same without Jenkins in the lineup. That's a credit to last year's team, but it also makes me wonder how much impact Jenkins really had. I'm going to say that it really won't end up being much of a difference, and Jenkins is always a threat to get hurt again, anyway.
JB: I tend to be in the minority on Gang Green Nation in thinking LaDainian Tomlinson does not have much left in the tank. A lot of our readers point to San Diego's run blocking? What were the causes of the back's recent struggles? What kind of year do you see him having?
The run-blocking certainly wasn't very good, but Tomlinson has clearly lost a step. He's lost his confidence -- he's indecisive on hitting the hole nowadays, and he doesn't have the speed to break away from linebackers and safeties at the second and third levels. I see him being a part-time player that uses his brain to serve as an effective blocker and receiver, but I don't see him being an effective rusher.
JB: A lot of our readers were upset the team let Jay Feely walk over the offseason and replaced him with Nick Folk. One thing to note, though, is the Jets used Feely's slot under final eight provisions to sign Jason Taylor. What do the numbers say? Are the Jets stronger with Feely or with Folk and Taylor?
BB: We've found that field goal conversion rate is almost totally random from year to year, and Feely's average at best on kickoffs, so losing him is no big deal. Unfortunately, Folk is one of the worst kickoff men in the league, so signing him was the wrong move. I would definitely take Taylor over Feely, but I'd prefer Taylor and (insert rookie with a strong leg here) over Taylor and Folk.
Many thanks to Bill for taking the time to chat with us. To be honest, I think he is way too negative on the Jets. Mark Sanchez isn't JaMarcus Russell. It was more about Sione Pouha stepping up, not Kris Jenkins being irrelevant. Cromartie and Wilson are both best at man coverage, which is what the Jets play.
Despite disagreements on matters of opinion, I have a world of respect for Mr. Barnwell. His work is very thought provoking and reasoned. He gets you thinking, even if you disagree, which is really the point of sites like ours and Football Outsiders.
Again, it's $21.95 at Amazon.com. You'll learn a lot about the league, particularly other teams. You'll get into the mood for the season. You'll also help out the friend of the site who wrote the book. It's a good work.
2 recs |
5 comments
|
Comments
Pouha stepped up huge last year when the Jets were in trouble, not sure how you can make a statement like that and claim to have watched much Jets fotball. That is were the stats let you down, he must have just looked at stats as opposed to watch many Jets games.
If that is the minority opinion about LT then a lot of people will be disappointed. I think he will add to the Jets as a second option back but that was a name grab as much as anything else. He has been ridden hard for a decade he is not superman.
I am not sure what to expect from Folk. I think kickers are more important then most football fans. Can Folk grab the Delorean and go back to 07? I hope the Jets saw something they can fix.
Since the face been revealed the game got real
Jenkins' impact
I think where he really should make a difference is in the pass rush. Him and Pouha are two different players—Pouha’s more of your standard space-eater NT, which he has shown he’s very good at. Jenkins (while being an abnormally large and strong man even at NT he’s still a space eater) is more of a penetrating defender. We’ve all seen him manhandle 330-lb linemen, tossing them aside like ragdolls in some cases.
It’s kind of strange, backwards-ish thinking, but it might be part of why we got less sacks at the beginning of the year last year. Of course Pace being out had a lot more to do with it, but Jenkins’ mere presence causes the opposing QB to speed the clock up in his head. We faced better QBs in the first half of the year than we did later on, guys who were already pretty good at getting the ball out quickly (Brady, Brees, Schaub). It all adds up doesn’t it!
How would a 4-3 with Jenkins and Pouha in the middle work?
Would that work or is their play much better suited for the 3-4? Because no team would be able to run against that. And with Revis in the backfield, that eliminates the inside run game and the #1 receiver. And perhaps Gholston would be able to better fit the 4-3 as well?
You might see that.
Although our base defenses is a 3-4, Rex mixes it up and you will see a lot of 4-3 packages with Pouha on the nose and Jenkins at end. But very interesting read. Rec’d as well.

by 


















