Rex Lists Potential Punt Return Replacements
Rex Ryan gave quite a laundry list of players who might return punts in place of Jim Leonhard.
We'll have a lot of options out there. We have a lot of guys that can return. You mentioned Joe McKnight and you have Kyle Wilson. Jerricho Cotchery (did it) last year. I think J-Co (Cotchery) could do it again if it's real windy. I know one thing, Jerricho will catch it, so I'm confident with him. We have guys like Santonio Holmes who have done it in the past and (Antonio) Cromartie. We have a lot of options there.
I keep waiting for Wilson to pop one. He has come close a few times and has looked elusive with the ball in his hands. If anything, the biggest issue is simply keeping his footing.
It's good to hear McKnight is working his way into the mix. He made a big play as a gunner on the punt coverage squad last week. If he has shown he has gotten over his fumbling issues, he might be a good choice. He is very dangerous in space. Think back to the return he had in preseason against Carolina.
Cotchery would be the logical guy for a situation where the team needed good hands out there and didn't care so much about getting a return. In other words, he would be Jim Leonhard 2.0.
I'm not so crazy about the idea of Holmes back there. He would be good, but he has become too big a part of the offense to risk. He has more value in the passing game than on returns.
I find Cromartie more tempting. I know the Jets need him in coverage. I know everybody under the sun will say "Jason Sehorn." He's just electric with the ball in his hands and would definitely add homerun potential. I understand it would be a gamble with a potential downside. It would also have upside. I'm not sure I'd want to see it full time, but I wouldn't mind seeing him back there if the team needed a spark.
18 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
I get excited watching Kyle Wilson improve as a punt returner. I really think we’ve got something really good in the near future there.
+100
He’s not a starter, doesn’t have fumble issues, has the most recent experience (this year and in college), and is arguably as dynamic as any player listed, this is a no brainer to me.
Actually Wilson does have fumble issues.
He fumbled against detroit and muffed one against baltimore on punt returns. that’s 2 fumbles on just 15 returns. there is no way I want McKinight or Wilson returning kicks on a cold Monday night game in Foxboro, Hands, hands, hands. J-Co is the right move. We don’t need a home run threat at PR to score points against the Patiots. Ball security is more important IMO. I understand they expected KW to be the guy, and he will be eventually, and it seems like they try to groom him by usually put him in there when the other team punts from inside their 10, giving KW more room to catch and run and gain more confidence. They should continue doing that, but I don’t want KW doing returns deep in our territory yet, or at all on Monday.
Its not like Cotch has the greatest hands...
he has like 7 fumbles in his career, and hasn’t returned a punt since the middle of last year, plus he’s not 100%. I agree he may be the best choice if its a short punt, but in most circumstances I’d prefer Wilson.
Cro
I with ya on cro. Every time he touches the rock I think “touchdown”. When he got that pick aganst palmer and broke the sound barrier to split two guys I thought he was gone. All he needs is just a sliver and he’ll fly. I want to see it. I don’t care about the risks. Deion did it in his day. Let him go. He would bust one.
by Crackback on Dec 3, 2010 9:41 PM EST via mobile reply actions
I thought I was the only 1 who thought that lol
Yea and we could really use the field position it always a plus
Haha. No way man there’s more of us than you think. The is just freaky dangerous with the ball. We just wanna see what he can do with some space.
by Crackback on Dec 4, 2010 11:25 AM EST via mobile up reply actions
It's not just the risk crack...
punt returning isn’t like KR, there is some decision making and skill to it, its something you need to be experienced in to know when to call the FC. As far as I know Cro. has 1 PR his entire NFL career, not sure if he returned at FS, but that would have been 5 years ago in college, just not worth the experiment.
I hear you. And its a good point. But I just want to see somebody with some pop back there for once. Somebody who, if they get thru the first wave, will be off to the races. I hated watching Jco returning last year when Jimmy busted his thumb. Part of me wants to see wilson but a bigger part is scared to death of hm either dropping it or fumbling it. Maybe he’ll perform better if they mAke him the guy, idk. Would really like to see McKnight but god forbid he muffs one, he’s just starting to build confidence, I don’t want to destroy it.
I trust Cro to catch it and he’s a huge threat with the ball in space. Remember that insane pick he had against baltimore? I have no idea how he came down with that. And then he almost took the thing all the way to the house. I just want to see him do it a couple times. If he can catch it clean, he should be the guy.
by Crackback on Dec 4, 2010 11:23 AM EST via mobile up reply actions
The truth is we should be using Cro. on KR...
I know Smith has been great so it may sound like blasphemy, but Cro. might be Hester good in Westys scheme.
That’s funny I was thinking the same thing but was affraid to post it bc it would get a slew of backlash.
He would be dynamite on kickoff returns. Wouldn’t mind seeing them both deep and running the reverse action. Might open up some lanes. And with those two you don’t need a lot of room, they both fly.
by Crackback on Dec 4, 2010 3:54 PM EST via mobile up reply actions
I like the idea of McKnight
if his fumbling issues are resolved to the point where the coaches trust him anyway. He looks like he could be explosive.
Wilson would be my second. Then it’s a toss up between Cro and J Cotch. I prefer to save either for their roles on their respective squads but trust either equally to be solid returners.
GGN Moderator, House pessimist, veteran arm chair coach.
www.GangGreenNation.com
I could see McKnight if we didn't have Wilson...
I don’t like using starters, and McKnight looked good in his limited time at PR during preseason, but Wilson is just as dynamic (if not more) and doesn’t have the fumble issues, he also has more experience doing it (both in the NFL and college).
cotch is good and all (i mean my lucky cotch jersey so far when wearing it we are 9-1)
but i got to say mcknight it always seems like when he get the ball (with out fumbling) he can just take it to the house giving him a go if not try wilson
Gang green nation!
we won the f*#&ing game now lets go get a goddamn snack!
Unproven rookies are not returning punts
In the biggest game of the season (thus far), as we approach the biggest month and beyond, the Jets will surely look to keep the ball in the hands of experienced players. McKnight and Wilson have not proven themselves to the point where the Jets coaching staff will willingly risk important games in exchange for whatever potential upside – if there are any – these players may bring to the punt return game. Look for Cotchery or Cromartie on Monday night. Both have experience and have done in important games and possessions.
voted cotch
First and foremost, because of the role Leonhard played on prs. He’s their “hands/head” guy deep inside the 20 and at certain situations late in games. With him out they need a similar player to fill that role and Cotch is the closest match imo. I agree that Cromo is electric with the ball in his hands, but I dont know how many reps he’s gotten with prs in practice, same concerns with Holmes. Also, Mcknight isnt ready for this spot yet, he’d be candidate perhaps in Wilson would go down, although then I’d vote Cro.
Also Wilson’s been looking better and better on returns, but perhaps its a bit premature to give him full duties, especially when this team is looking to make a super bowl run, one drop punt can end a season and make you a goat for a long time.

by 






















