Gang Green Nation: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
New Blog: Once A Metro covering Red Bull New York!

The Top Five Second Guess New York Jets Roster Moves This Decade

Second guesses are pointless. There's nothing less constructive you can ever do than look back at the past and complain about something that didn't happen. You can always make the right moves with hindsight. Hitting 100% of your decisions is impossible. With that said, today we're going to look back at the five most questionable roster moves or non moves the Jets have made this decade. Who ever said fans have to be rationale or spend time productively?

On this list, I have only included moves that have hurt the team that frustrated me at the time.

Star-divide

5. The Vilma trade:

I know the talking points. People say Jonathan Vilma is better in the 4-3. I think the team gave up on him in the 3-4 too soon. Part of his problem was the lack of supporting talent. It's tough to play linebacker when linemen are blowing Dewayne Robertson off the ball and getting to you easily. Vilma would have had much more room to operate if he ever got the chance to play behind Kris Jenkins. I get that David Harris is a better inside linebacker in the 3-4, but there are two inside linebackers in the scheme. Jon's life would have been easier next to Harris. Opponents would have had to make Harris the focal point instead of Vilma. Look at how successful opposing tight ends were against the Jets in 2008. Do you mean to tell me the Jets wouldn't have been better with Vilma and his cover skills in the lineup  instead of Eric Barton? Barton wasn't the reason Gang Green was so good against the run.

4. The Pete Kendall fiasco:

The offensive line was one of the biggest question marks entering the 2006 season. It ended up being one of the team's primary strengths and one of the foremost reasons Gang Green had a surprising 10 win Playoff season. Kendall was a source of stability starting between a pair of rookies. During the offseason, the Jets had plenty of cap room. Kendall asked for a $1 million raise. A year earlier, Kendall reworked his deal when the Jets were in trouble with the cap. Instead of rewarding Pete by quietly giving him a raise, the team took a hard line and turned it into a public standoff. Kendall kept taking shots at the front office in the media. Eric Mangini stripped him of his starting spot and made him stay in the rookie dorms at training camp. Eventually, the Jets traded Pete to Washington for a fifth round pick. The team had no replacement at left guard. Adrien Clarke took over the slot and played brutally. He was out of the league the next year. The line took a major step back. The team went 4-12 and had to give Alan Faneca a megadeal during the offseason to address the position. If only the Jets had been willing to pay that $1 million, they could have avoided this.

3. The Justin McCareins trade:

The Jets needed a starting wide receiver. Terry Bradway gave up a second round pick for a guy who couldn't catch a cold and got progressively worse in each of his four seasons in New York. The same offseason, Baltimore was willing to part with a second round pick for Terrell Owens.

2. Bryan Thomas over Ed Reed:

It's tough to go crazy over misses in the Draft. Great players get passed over by a lot of teams. It's impossible to tell who will turn into a great player and who will be a bust. The Jets' first round pick in 2002 made no sense at the time, though. Gang Green had struggled to find quality safety play for years. The front office tried everything from signing a proven veteran like Steve Atwater and even trying to convert a college quarterback, Scott Frost. Nothing worked. Reed was the top rated safety in the Draft and fell to 22. I would understand it if the Jets looked to address another positon, but they took a defensive end, Thomas, even though they already had a pair of promising young defensive ends starting for them, Shaun Ellis and John Abraham. I think drafting by need is usually a mistake, but this was a case where best player met need. The Jets went instead to a position at which they were sent. Reed has a Defensive Player of the Year Award and five All Pro selections. Would he have been as good developing with the Jets instead of with the surrounding talent on the Ravens? Maybe not but how great would it have be to see Reed and Kerry Rhodes lining up next to each other?

1. Not trading for Randy Moss:

Nobody ever thinks of this, but the Jets were a very logical fit for Randy Moss after the 2006 season. They were an up and coming team after a surprising Playoff run. It looked like they were emerging as a legitimate challenger in the AFC East after an upset win in Foxborough in the regular season and a competitive showing up there in the Playoffs. What the Jets lacked was a gamebreaking player on offense. The Raiders were ready to give Randy Moss away. Moss wanted to go to a contender. The Jets had a ton of cap space. Moss played with Chad Pennington in college. Talk all you want about Chad's arm strength. He can get the ball 40 yards down the field. It doesn't matter how badly the ball is thrown. Moss can readjust and outleap anybody on a jump ball. Gang Green had a stable locker room after a Playoff year. The Jets could have annouced to the league they were contenders by making the bold splash of trading for Randy. Instead, the team traded for Thomas Jones and picked up assorted journeymen to fill out the roster. There was no bold move that offseason. The coaching staff and front office seemed to get arrogant. The Jets didn't have a ton of talent in 2006, and the men in charge thought the surprising run was due to coaching, not a ridiculously soft schedule. They thought they could turn any group into a winner. They were wrong. Moss went to New England and blew the gap between the teams wide open once again. The Jets gave up a fourth round pick for Kevan Barlow but wouldn't for Randy Moss.

What move or non move since 2000 frustrates you most? Have I missed something that should be here? Am I being too hard on the front office on some of these?

0 recs  |  Comment 8 comments |

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

I would have put Kendall as #1. At least this decade is looking much better then the 90s, 2 words, Browning Nagle.

The Jets would have never traded for Moss cause he’s trouble. As long as thats #1, you can say that the Jets should have traded for Owens.

On Vilma, you never know when an injury is going to flat out end his career, he has osteochondritis dissecans so you never know when he’s going to get hurt.

by WebBard on Jul 26, 2009 3:16 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

I think you're overreacting about Kendall

Sure, the Jets sort of owed Kendall the raise and yes, he was a great guard for us, but you make it sound as if the way it wound up for us by signing Alan Faneca was a bad thing. Of course hindsights 20/20 right now, but our offensive line is much better off right now with Faneca than Kendall. Kendall can’t even find a job now. Faneca’s among the best guards in the NFL.

by joey d on Jul 26, 2009 7:39 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Two Words for you

Doug Jolley. At the time, I thought Jolley would be a serviceable player. Not the kind you give up a first round pick for (I know that the Jets got a second round pick back, but still) In addition to drafting Nugent, which I didn’t like at the time (although, to be fair, I have to admit he was very good at times,) the Jets gave up the 26th pick for a player they had for one year and then traded to TB for a 6th round pick. Just to torture ourselves (which we love to do, since we’re Jets fans,) let’s take a look at the 5 players picked after that pick, any one of whom the Jets could have had.

27. Roddy White
28. Luis Castillo
29. Marlin Jackson
30. Heath Miller
31. Mike Patterson
32. Logan Mankins

Then, to make matters worse, the two 2nd round picks, Justin Miller and Nugent, are no longer with the team

by njmetfan12 on Jul 27, 2009 1:20 AM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Outsiders take

The Kendall fiasco sticks out to me, because of the concequences – a year of terrible O-line play and a 4-12 record – the predictability of the result, and the small cost of avoiding it.

by hythlodaeus on Jul 27, 2009 9:26 AM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Dude you nailed it.

While it’s true that we got Faneca out of the deal the cost was tremendous. I don’t think many Jets fans would have been consoled after the 4-12 season with “well at least it bought you Faneca next year.” No matter how you slice it, it just comes off as yet another demoralizing round of “wait ’til next year”.

Xander is Editor-In-Chief for AFCBeast.com - The Best Damn Jets Fan Site Ever!

by Xander Diaz on Jul 27, 2009 11:58 AM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Really silly article

This is the type of ill informed article I would expect from NY’s professional media. Shame on you. Most of these points were just silly.

Lets go backwards and review why all but one these points were dumb and are in no way subject to second guessing by intelligent informed fans:

1) Randy Moss would not have signed with the Jets. We were not a super bowl winning team with Tom Brady. The Pats got him for cheap because no other team was a viable trade partner given his contract situation and willingness to be a jerk supreme if not happy.

2) Picking BLT over anyone was dumb. He was the type of workout warrior that wowed Bradway and kept him from accurately evaluating talent. But what is dumb is picking Reed as the guy we should have picked instead. A lot of other teams who went before us wish they too had picked Reed. The draft is a crap shoot and after the top 3-5 picks, there is nothing but uncertainty. This was not a dumb point but I resent folks saying we should have picked Tom Brady when 32 other teams blew it for six rounds. It is one thing to blame Bradway for picking a workout warrior. It is another to blame him for not being prescient.

3) Stone hands was addition by subtraction then and now. What a worthless POS. In spite of the uncertainty of our WR core, I am supremely confident that someone on our roster is better than MacUseless. How soon some of us forget how bad a WR can be.

4) It is hard to follow this site’s rules of propriety regarding this. Kendall was under contract. He was a declining player who mouthed off. To shut him up we would still be paying for this guy who the Skins, who need OL help, just cut. In his first season with the Skins, his missed block on 4th and 1 at the goal line saved the Jints season — in effect giving the Jints a SB (they’d have missed the cut had they lost that game). That was not the only missed block by Kendall that season or last season. He was no loss and his attitude prevented us from dealing fairly with him. No second guessing here although I wish we had better evaluated the talent we relied on to replace him. That evaluation by Mangini and his coaches is ripe for second guessing, not getting rid of Kendall. Good riddance to bad rubbish. Too bad the NY Mediaots who were like vampires thirsting for his inside stuff played up his side of the story to the point that even kendall had to admit he misspoke when he accused Tanny of lying.

5) Vilma was another guy we were lucky to trade for anything. He was coming up for a contract renewal, did not fit in our system, was too small/slow for a 3-4, and we would never have offered him what NO eventually gave him after letting him become a FA in order to save their #1 pick. Our inside LB are better now than at any time in recent memory.

Harlan

by hlachman on Jul 28, 2009 10:47 AM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about the New York Jets.
Start posting about the Jets »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

Connect_with_facebook

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Small
SB Nation Survey + Chance to donate $500 to a charity of this community's choice
Small
Running Backs by Round
Small
Cromartie's endorsement opportunity.
3241_91465347993_548377993_2506906_323366_n_small
Why L.T. is a Great Signing
Gangreen-large_small
Sign Up for the Gang Green Nation Community Mock Draft

Recent FanPosts

Great-british-events-flag_small
Saturday Night Open Thread
Small
Jets potential Drafting Scenarios
Small
jets work out Iupati
Small
Mike Iupati -- Can We Afford to Pass Him Up?
Small
Owusu-Ansah FS?
Small
Osi Revisited
Me_as_a_simpson_small
Represent Your Team in MHR's Live Mock!
New-york-sack-exchange_small
Some Interesting Prospective Players

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Latest NFL Headlines from SB Nation

SBNation.com Recent Stories

Photo link

A Deeper Look At The 2009 Cowboys Running Game

Photo +1 updates

Rams, Redskins Showing Interest In QB Sam Bradford

Photo +3 updates

Trent Baalke Reportedly Taking Over 49ers GM Duties

More from SBNation.com >


Managing Editors

Gangreen-large_small John B

Great-british-events-flag_small David_Wyatt

Staff Writers

943_small dvdvil

Jets_logo_small Matt Birch

Contributing Writers

Small Russ H

Afcbeast_beast_small Xander Diaz