Are Draft Picks Valued Too Highly?

by John B on Jun 24, 2009 2:00 PM EDT Comment 1 comment

I was thinking. Isn't it strange the way Draft picks are valued? It seemed like before the Draft everybody thought a first round pick was too much to give up for Anquan Boldin. Had the Jets wanted a receiver and stayed at 17, they would have ended up with Jeremy Maclin. Maclin might not have demanded as big of a contract, but what are the odds he ends up as good as Boldin?

How about quarterbacks? Remember the Jay Cutler rumors? A first and a third round pick seemed like a really steep down payment. Then the Jets trade a first, a second, and two players for Mark Sanchez. People said that was a cheap price to grab the number 5 pick. I was never the biggest Cutler fan, but he is a proven commodity. Sanchez started in college for a year. Shouldn't the perception be reversed?

On the other hand, the league tends to show the value of drafting well. Teams like the Redskins that don't value their picks and constantly splurge on big names are not relevant. The league has a salary cap. Too many big contracts can bankrupt a team for years. Football's also a team game. In basketball, one player can carry a franchise. Aside from Peyton Manning, it's tough to come up with too many examples in the NFL.

Big contracts are based on past production. Shelf lives are not very long in a sport this violent. Most Draft picks sign cheaper contracts and provide quality play for a longer time than established players.

There's a case to be made for both sides. What do you think?

Poll

Do teams value Draft picks too highly?

Yes

125 votes

No

37 votes

162 votes | Poll has closed

0 recs | Comment 1 comment | Share

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

I think the problem is two fold. First off, in any league, Potential is going to exceed what you already have. Potentially wise Lawrence Philips could be a better back then Jerome Bettis was on draft day. Unfortunately Potential has a tendency in the NFL (especially with first rounders) to be unfufilled. Look at when the Saints traded an insane amount of picks to get Ricky Williams. Everyone was talking as though the Redskins were going to be on an upswing and a great franchise because of it, but now one of the keys in that trade (Washington’s 2000 1st rounder) is Lavarr Arrignton who is retired.

The second problem is drafting from the colleges. With 128 (I think) divison 1 teams, how can you see through the bs. A team like Hawaii keeps having QBs who put up insane stats against inferior players. Or how can you tell when a player is only as good as the players around him. USC QBs Carson Palmer and Matt Leinart spent the season on the bench and out of action while their backup QB in college put up insane numbers for having never started a College game.

by WebBard on Jun 25, 2009 2:42 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs